Why Canadian Pediatricians Are Warning Against Teen Dieting

For generations, the conversation around teen health has often revolved around one thing: weight. From school health classes to doctor’s appointments, the focus on numbers on a scale and Body Mass Index (BMI) has been the standard. But what if this approach was doing more harm than good? That’s the exact question being answered by the Canadian Paediatric Society (CPS). In a significant shift, the CPS has issued updated guidelines that address a growing crisis in adolescent health. They are urging healthcare providers to move away from weight-focused care due to the profound risks it poses to young people. The message is clear and urgent. As the CPS stresses, “dieting during adolescence can have serious and lasting physical and mental health consequences.” Let’s explore what these new guidelines mean, why they are so important, and how parents and caregivers can help foster true, lasting health for the teens in their lives.

The Problem with Weight-Focused Care

For years, the default advice for a teen in a larger body was often a simple prescription: “eat less, move more.” This weight-centric model assumed that weight was the primary indicator of health and that dieting was the solution.

However, a growing body of evidence shows this approach is not only ineffective but deeply damaging. Focusing on weight can trigger a cascade of negative outcomes, including:

• Weight Stigma: Creating feelings of shame and failure, which can lead to social withdrawal and avoidance of physical activity.
• Disordered Eating: Encouraging restrictive behaviours, calorie counting, and an unhealthy obsession with food.
• Poor Body Image: Teaching teens to judge their self-worth based on a number, leading to anxiety and depression.

The CPS recognizes that this old model is failing our kids. The pressure to achieve a certain body size is contributing to a public health problem that goes far beyond weight itself.

The Hidden Dangers of Dieting for Teens

Adolescence is a critical period of physical and neurological development. Restricting calories or cutting out entire food groups can have devastating effects that last a lifetime.

1. Physical Health Consequences: A teen’s body needs a wide range of nutrients to build strong bones, develop healthy organs, and support hormonal changes. Dieting can lead to:

• Nutrient deficiencies that impact growth and brain function.
• Disruption of the menstrual cycle.
• Poor bone density, increasing the risk of osteoporosis later in life.
• Metabolic changes that can actually lead to long-term weight gain (the “yo-yo” effect).

2. Mental and Emotional Toll: The mental impact is often the most severe. Dieting is a significant predictor for the development of clinical eating disorders like anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, and binge-eating disorder. Even if it doesn’t lead to a full-blown disorder, it can fuel:

• Constant anxiety about food choices.
• Depression and low self-esteem.
• Social isolation, as teens may avoid events involving food.
• A toxic relationship with food and their own body.

A New Direction: Focusing on Behaviours, Not Body Weight

So, if we move away from weight, what do we move toward? The CPS advocates for a weight-inclusive approach.

This isn’t about ignoring health. It’s about redefining it.

Instead of focusing on the number on the scale, this new model encourages healthcare providers and families to focus on promoting healthy, sustainable behaviours for teens of all sizes.

Key pillars of a weight-inclusive approach include:

• Promoting a Healthy Relationship with Food: Teaching intuitive eating—honouring hunger and fullness cues—and enjoying a variety of foods without guilt.
• Encouraging Joyful Movement: Shifting the focus from exercising to lose weight to finding physical activities that are fun and feel good, like dancing, hiking, team sports, or swimming.
• Fostering Positive Body Image: Helping teens appreciate and respect their bodies for what they can do, not just how they look.
• Improving Overall Well-being: Prioritizing sleep, stress management, and strong social connections as essential components of health.

What Parents and Caregivers Can Do

This shift starts at home. You have the power to change the conversation and create a supportive environment where your teen can thrive.

• Ban “Fat Talk”: Do not speak negatively about your own body, your teen’s body, or anyone else’s. Model body positivity and acceptance.
• Remove Labels from Food: Avoid calling foods “good,” “bad,” “junk,” or “guilt-free.” Instead, talk about foods in terms of what they do for our bodies—providing energy, building muscle, or simply being delicious.
• Eat Meals Together: Family meals are a powerful tool for modeling a healthy relationship with food and connecting with your teen.
• Focus on How They Feel: Shift compliments away from appearance. Instead of “You look so slim,” try “You look so strong and happy on the soccer field!” or “You seem to have so much energy today.”
• Seek the Right Support: If you have concerns about your teen’s health, find a family doctor, paediatrician, or registered dietitian who understands and practices from a weight-inclusive perspective.

Building a Healthier Future

The new guidelines from the Canadian Paediatric Society are a crucial step forward. They validate what many parents and teens have felt for years: that a relentless focus on weight is painful and counterproductive.

By shifting our focus from weight to well-being—from dieting to living—we can help our teens build a foundation of physical and mental health that will support them for the rest of their lives.

Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Please consult with a qualified healthcare provider for any health concerns or before making any changes to your health regimen.